[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape and the Penseive

[John and Peg]

No: HPFGUIDX 84071

evil_sushi2003 <evil_sushi2003 at hotmail.com> wrote: 
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Robert Jones" 
<jones.r.h.j at w...> wrote:
> In OOTP Snape put three memories in the Pensieve, and I was 
thinking 
> what the other two might be -- might he be trying to hide whether 
he 
> was a double agent spying for LV? something more about Lily? -- 
and 
> whether Harry would be able to learn more from the past.  

ES
Hmm... Ive often wondered about the other two memories in Snape's 
pensieve... I would expect the three memories to be kept hidden 
would be 

1) showing reason's for Snape's deep hatred of James, Sirius,(the 
one which we've seen in OotP)

2) showing the turning point whcih effected Snape enough to spy for 
the order (i'm thinking along the lines of using a forbidden curse 
on someone he cared for/ knew was completely innocent/ had a deep 
respect for)

3) probably some 'adult' stuff... need I say anymore

>But then I 
> thought that since Snape wouldn't be giving Harry any more 
> Occulmency lessons Snape wouldn't bother putting any memories he 
> didn't want Harry to see in there.  But then I thought that if 
Snape 
> is in fact spying for the Order, he might put memories he does not 
> want LV to know in there before a spying mission.  So the Penseive 
> may come up in Book6 or 7.  Harry may stumble onto more knowledge 
of 
> the past if he ends up in Snape's office when Snape is on a 
mission.

I think that one of the memories is the reason why DD trusts Snape so much. IMO only Snape (and others like him) would think that someone else knowing this would be considered a weakness.

Notjust1



---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Protect your identity with Yahoo! Mail AddressGuard

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]