First name adressing = same House? + Snape the Vampire (yes, again)
annemehr
annemehr at yahoo.com
Thu Nov 6 03:58:06 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 84186
Inge wrote:
> I wonder in which house Hagrid was back then - do we have any canon
> to tell?
> The reason I wonder is because in CoS (chapter 13) Tom Riddle and
> Hagrid adress each other by first name:
>
> "'Evening, Rubeus,' said Riddle sharply. The boy slammed the door
> shut and stood up. 'What yer doin' down here, Tom?'"
>
> Riddle and Hagrid were 2 years apart when they were at Hogwarts and
> it seems a bit strange that they use first names (and this was in the
> 40's when I assume that using last names was even more common between
> people who didn't socialise with each other?)
Annemehr:
I'd never really paid any attention to that before, other than that it
shows they were personally acquainted with each other.
But you're quite right. Their use of first names suggests something
much more than mere acquaintance. What if Hagrid actually thought
they were *friends?* Then Riddle didn't just use him as a scapegoat,
he betrayed him. Probably know all about that acromantula because
Hagrid had told him all about it. And now he just carries on with how
his life has turned out, never complaining, hardly a harsh word to say
about anybody. I'll bet it turns out he's a lot deeper than any of us
thought.
And there's no way I think Hagrid could have been in Slytherin. He's
just not the Slytherin type. It's just that Riddle was charming to
people all over the school, in case he needed to make use of them.
Annemehr
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive