Slytherin Sirius?, was: Of course Snape is a Slytherin
nibleswik
nibleswik at yahoo.com
Tue Nov 11 06:43:08 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 84597
> > > Knowing now that Snape is a good guy playing double agent.
What
> > house
> > > do you think he was in??
Cheekyweebisom:
> > Slytherin, obviously. I'll say it AGAIN: Slytherin =/= evil.
<lots of snipping>
Tonya:
> I wasn't trying to be smart.... I have been enjoying all
> the "House"
> discussions. I really thought that Black was a Slytherin and now
> after
> all these wonderful posts I am not sure. I was also sure that
> Snape was
> a Slytherin. Although I have not found canon to back that up!!
> I think that good wizards can and do come from Slytherin.
Me (Cheekyweebisom):
Oh, sure. I'm sorry if I seemed brusque; the "Slytherins are ESE!"
statements really get to me, though. It just seems SO simplistic.
I'm interested in why so many people think/thought Sirius was a
Slytherin. I don't get it at all: he's not particularly
cunning or ambitious, though he IS very, very brave (and is
described as such by DD himself), he was best friends with James,
and his mother hates him. These all seem to point to Gryffindor,
don't they? What points to Slytherin? I'm very curious.
Cheekyweebisom
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive