Do Wizards Always...?
S & R Ranch
sandrranch at yahoo.com
Tue Nov 11 08:07:14 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 84608
Do wizards always make noise when they apparate and disapparate? I am
asking because in book five everyone seems to me making noise when
they do so. Also in several of the previous books you read about the
noise...even Dobby the House Elf made a noise when he apparates and
disapparates. Yet he simply appears in the hedge and Harry's bedroom
on Privit Drive with no sound. I assume House Elfs have numerous
abilities and one that would allow them to appear and vanish with out
making a sound in order to perform their duties without disturbing
the household. So I can see how Dobby can come and go with out making
a sound if he chooses to do so.
Yet when Hagrid disappears at the train station in book one there
seem not to be any noise. I honestly don't know how someone of
Hagrid's size could vanish as he did unless he disapparated.
So I assume you can choose to either make or not make a sound when
you apparate or disapparate. I would think one in the WW would need
to be able to control this noise.
What do you think?
sandrranch
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive