[HPforGrownups] Re: Challenging Lexicon timeline (was Ron's dead brother)

[SnapesSlytherin at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 85504

Erin wrote:
And I would love to know where that came from.  In SS, the twins make it sound as if they were at school with Charlie "WE haven't won since Charlie left"  That would make Charlie two years older than Percy, leaving a season in between for the Gryffindors to have lost.

Now Oryomai:
Just saying "We haven't won since Charlie left" doesn't mean anything.  I say things like "We haven't won PIMBA since Amanda left!" (It's a marching band thing...) But I wasn't in band when she was.  "We" can just mean the team/House itself.  To give this some canon, I think that the Dead Weasley will be true.  This could explain why Mr. Weasley describes seeing the Dark Mark over a house so well.

Oryomai