Timeline for ages & events (updated yet again)

hermowninny719 hermowninny719 at yahoo.com
Wed Nov 26 18:36:23 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 85904

bboy_mn wrote:
Bill says in Gof that he hasn't seen Hogwarts in 5 years, but that by 
no means implies that 5 years ago was when he graduated.  It just 
happens to be the last time he visited the school. So, this reference 
can't really be used to establish either Charlie or Bill school 
years. It's no more significant that the last time I visited the 
grocery store.

Marci wrote:
Why not imply that is when he graduated?  Why would that summize a 
visit?  For what reason does Bill have to visit Hogwarts?  If it can 
be assumed that he visited, it can also be assumed that is when he 
graduated.


Now Hermowninny writes:
Perhaps this *tiny* quote can be used in the BB GUN theory currently 
floating around.  What if he graduated in 1984, then had some ever so 
evil reason to return to Hogwarts in the spring of 1990?   Hmmm, what 
else happened in 1990--Fudge became MoM, Quirrel took a year off 
(maybe), what else...  Hey, maybe Bill filled in for Quirrel when he 
was gone--but, then again, maybe it was for some much more evil 
reason!  Erin, Oliver, where are you?

-Hermowninny





More information about the HPforGrownups archive