Crying Wolf?

[voldermort_is_harry]

No: HPFGUIDX 82052

>Talisman, loving another look at PoA says:
 
>I agree with Kneasy et al. who find Lupin's "epiphany" implausible. 
>There are too many dots to connect, too many alternative scenerios 
>and even if you guessed right, you'd want to hear it from Sirius, 
>rather than feed him the explanation.  It smells to high heaven of 
>pre-arrangement.

There is another, simpler explination:  Before Sirius was shipped off 
to Azkaban, he told his story to Remus.  Remus didn't believe him, 
for one reason or another.  However, after seening Peter on the M-
Map, he realizes that what Sirius had said was true.  

No canon, of course, but the exchange in the Shack does suggest that 
*some* previous communication took place.


'bin'