[HPforGrownups] Re: Why is everyone so convinced the prophecy is correct?

[Iggy McSnurd]

No: HPFGUIDX 82338



> Tim:
>
> I think you're missing something.  Harry picked the orb up off the
> shelf.  If the prophecy had really been about Neville and not about
> Harry, then Harry would have ended up in St Mungo's like Bode (I
> think it was Bode who tried to get it under Voldy's command) did.  It
> was made clear that the prophesy orb could only be taken by the person
> (s) the phophesy was about... then, and only then, could someone else
> touch it.

Yes, but since it's never been made 100% clear that it DOESN'T mean Neville,
there's the possibility that either of them could have picked it up off the
shelf, yes?

After all, what's on the placecard is just how someone else wrote it, it's
not necessarily what dictates who can pick up the globe.  Yes?


Iggy McSnurd
the Prankster

"I Ate My Other Car"
"... and your little dog too!"

-- Two of the bumper stickers Iggy has, in the order he found them.
(Otherwise, he wouldn't have bought the second one.)