Is Neville's frog Trevor and animagus?

[deedeee88]

No: HPFGUIDX 83380

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "splnyc" <sluther.nyc at v...> 
wrote:
> I can't find anywhere this topic has been covered already, but I 
> heard that there is a new theory that Neville's frog Trevor could 
> actually be Dolores Umbridge? I am re-reading book 5 right now and 
> want to check it out again for myself, but could this be true? 
> Dolores Umbridge is always described as frog-like and I can't find 
> any scenes where Trevor and Dolores are at the same place at the 
> same time. Could Dolores be Neville's other grandmother (his 
> maternal grandmother, Alice's mother) and perhaps be keeping an eye 
> on Neville as his pet frog is SS, CS, PA and GF? Then in OOP we 
> don't see Trevor and Umbridge at the same time because Umbridge is 
> at Hogwarts and is keeping an eye on Neville in her human form? It 
> could even explain why Umbridge wants to deny so much that 
Voldemort 
> is not back - she is still too upset from her daughter's death and 
> wants to stay in denial that he could come back. She does not want 
> to believe it could be true. This could all be crazy but I was 
> curious if anyone out there has heard this or had similar thoughts.



DeeDee here:

It may well be that Neville's toad is an animagus.

But most likely, IMHO, the prime candidate would be his "Uncle Algie" 
or even his Grandma...

Hence, this is why trevor is always "missing"...(lost)..uncle Algie 
exploring....Grandma thinking to herself "okay he's here now under 
DD's and Hogwarts protection."

Perhaps Neville knows this now and this is why in book five he has 
his "cactus/plant" and is more caring about that than being 
particularly worried about Trevor.
Neville seldom if ever, "tells",  perhaps his family, like many 
posters here are just as concerned for his protection.  Because 
whether or not Harry/Neville is the ONE...If we, as readers suddenly 
jump to the conclusion that the ONE is Neville the we may assume 
Volemort will too. Is this why Snape is so angry with Neville all the 
time...because he steered Voldemort the Potter way (given past 
history) rather than Neville's way?!???

And I don't care what anyone says, I'm still leaning towards Lilly 
being a wayward decendant of Slytherin...hence the "get out of the 
way silly girl"...and why Volde went after Harry first---mark as an 
equal thing---Voldemort went after the "most equal" first.

Neville needs protection...he still can be "marked as an equal"..

DeeDee