First prediction's happened, third possible?
sbursztynski
greatraven at hotmail.com
Mon Oct 27 02:07:45 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 83632
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Paul Smith" <suzie_t666 at h...>
wrote:
> > If Harry had the power to defeat his opponent (especially in
war),
> then he has already done it. Voldemort was comprehensively
defeated
> at Godric's Hollow, and it took him 14 years and the help of a
> servant to be able to reply.
>
> The fact that one of them has to die is trickier, but Voldemort was
> *hit* by an Avada Kedavra, and so in theory did die. His spirit
left
> his body as in death (I wonder what happened to that original
body),
> but his spirit, through whatever spell or transformation Voldemort
> had managed, stayed in this world, rather than going on to the
next.
>
Sue B:
What a great idea! I have been thinking that this prophecy *had* to
have a loophole somewhere, because I can't believe that JKR is going
to force Harry to become a murderer, however justified. Nor do I
think LV is going to win in the end. So there has to be a loophole
(not sure how one would reveal that unless DD suddenly leaps up and
says, "Of course! How could I have been so stupid?" which is also not
impossible, given that Gandalf, whom he most resembles, spent ages
trying to open that door in Moria when there was a simple password).
So quite probably LV will end up doing it to himself, somehow, or
perhaps Peter will do it (Wormtongue, <g> rather than the Gollum
we've all been considering him).
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive