Only Living Relative... REVISITED

ghinghapuss rredordead at aol.com
Wed Oct 29 22:49:47 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 83826

> bboy_mn said:
> Dumbledore speaks...
> "...She gave you a lingering protection he never expexted, a
> protextion that flows in our veins tothis day. I put my trust,
> therefore, in your mother's blood. I delivered you to her sister, 
her
> ONLY REMAINING RELATIVE."

Now me:
I wouldn't trust everything Dumbldore says.  Yes he's good and all 
that but he can fudge the truth when it suits him and more 
importantly if it suits the future of the WW. 

Petunia and family were in a much more of a suitable position to 
raise the infant Harry than Mark, who I believe to be younger than 
Harry and therefore not born at the time of Harry's parents murder. 
What about Mark's parents you ask? Well, who says they are alive, 
perhaps he is living with adopted parents too.  

Another reason for Dumbledore to lie is if Harry's mother's family 
present a danger to him or could reveal a terrible secret about that 
side of the family Dumbledore wants to keep quiet as long as 
possible.  

Just a thought.
Mandy








More information about the HPforGrownups archive