Wizards and the Queen
o_caipora
o_caipora at yahoo.com
Thu Oct 30 17:54:51 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 83869
How often is the Queen used in British fiction?
It's fairly common in American fiction to use the President. He's
someone who's automatically "important", and as such he attracts
bestseller authors the same way Death attracts teenage writers.
But I'm not sure the Queen is used in the same way. P.G. Wodehouse
has endless earls and baronets, and Saki makes liberal use of
Duchesses. But never the Queen.
There was a film set in a British board school some thirty years
ago, "If...", where the climactic scene is a birthday assembly for
the very ancient school. Someone at the assembly addresses someone
else - who IIRC was not even visible - as "Highness", which would be
a member of the royal family, but not the queen who would
be "Majesty".
I'm not referring to historical fiction, which may follow different
rules. Though IIRC in Daphne du Maurier's "The King's General" the
King never appears directly. American fiction or movies set in
England doesn't count, either.
So - three possibilities:
1) When Rowling mentions the Prime Minister but not the Queen, she's
merely following British literary convention.
2) The above is not true, and failure to mention the Queen tells us
something about the Wizarding World.
3) She's waiting to be knighted, after which Her Majesty gets a cameo
scene - or perhaps bashes Voldemort over the head with her sceptre,
vanquishing him single-handedly, if Rowling is ennobled.
Can anyone shed some light on this?
- Caipora
Lola said:
> That would make the Queen the official Head of State of the
> British wizarding community.
> However, functionally, the Minister of Magic must be the Head of
> State because the Queen can hardly have an in-depth knowledge about
> wizarding affairs, can she?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive