James Potter Still Alive?

[rach9112000]

No: HPFGUIDX 81781

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Arya" 
> >As for your point # 3, with Trewlawney, I think this one is not explained away by my reasons, however, I do think it may be a supporting argument to the 
Lupin's boggart is not a moon but a crystal prophecy sphere of some sort. It 
may have been that Remus witnessed Trewlawney give a prophecy (they 
always seem to be given to those who are close to the actual ones involved or 
the events prophesized about), and that the prophecy was something Remus 
"feared" and since he knew there was a recording about it, he fears anyone 
finding out and therefore, fears the prophecy recording that might allow 
someone to hear it. He also would flee before the prospect of hearing 
another prophecy. >>>


Maybe I'm wrong but I assumed the prophecy that Lupin was scared 
of on seeing the boggart was the one between Harry and Voldemort. 
This makes sense to me because if Harry is ultimately defeated by 
Voldemort then Voldemort will be around forever to attack the 
wizarding world. This seems quite a reasonable thing for Lupin to 
fear.

 Rachel