Death Chamber/ancient magic

[Naama]

No: HPFGUIDX 81906

Urghiggi wrote:
 And just because the only example given (lily's sacrifice) is 
> love-based -- does this necessarily rule out the possibility that 
there may be 
> other aspects of this ancient magic that are morally neutral or 
even dark? 
> Again, we don't have enough info to know ... yet.

*Naama activates a big red WRONG! buzzer*

LV *has* already used ancient magic in a very dark way - his revival 
potion in the end of GoF (not an exact quote): "it's a piece of old 
magic, the potion that revived me tonight..." All the "bone of the 
father" etc. sounds pretty ancient to me. 

So there is ancient dark magic. As for morally neutral magic, I 
can't really see how that can work. It seems to me that ancient 
magic needs some sort of emotional or magical base, that does not 
allow the spell to stay morally neutral.

Just a thought...

--Naama