Snape and Lucius -- same person? (was Re: Re-reading CoS : questions, and more about Penny)

[Tim Cuthbertson]

No: HPFGUIDX 94938

Del :
> I do believe that originally Snape and Malfoy were two different 
> beings. I'm just wondering if one of them didn't get killed and 
> the other is filling in while still keeping his real identity. 
> Snape, for example, would have every reason to do that: it would 
> allow him to spy on LV and his DEs, while keeping in contact with 
> DD. 

But, how can Lucius and Snape be the same person? They may not have 
been seen together in the books but in second film they watch the 
Quidditch match together!!
 
You may say that this proves nothing, but JKR has forced certain 
scenes to be put into the films (eg Voldy killing HP mother in 
Godric's Hollow). If Snape and Lucius were the same person, she would 
never have allowed this!!

Tim