Is Wormtaiil an Occlumens?
justcarol67
justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Tue Apr 6 00:35:27 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 95266
Corinth wrote:
> Very likely, but the question remains whether Pettigrew had anything
> to hide when he first joined the Order. My impression has always
> been that he was part of the Order for a while before Voldemort
> approached him. Otherwise, why would Voldemort have wanted him for
a spy in the first place? No extreme abilities (no well-known
> abilities, at least), no record of reliability, whiny and annoying,
> etc. Given Peter's track record in school, Voldemort could hardly
> have expected Dumbledore to simply accept him into the Order, no
> questions asked, simply for showing interest. If the plan was to
> insert a spy as a new member of the Order, there must have been
> better candidates out there.
>
> Instead, Voldemort took a look at those he knew were in the Order
and asked himself, "Who can I most easily cooerce/threaten into giving
me some information?" Peter was an obvious choice.
>
> So it is entirely possible that Peter was able to pass Dumbledore's
> legilimency test when first joining, not due to Occlumency, but due
> to the fact that he wasn't yet a spy.
Carol responds:
I agree that Peter was in the Order before he became a spy and I don't
think he was an Occlumens. But how would LV know who was in the Order
unless a spy had informed him, and who could that spy have been other
than Peter?
Carol, with apologies for the short post
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive