Does LV know Snape is at Hogwarts?

Jim Ferer jferer at yahoo.com
Wed Apr 14 22:32:43 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 95983

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "soccerboyatut2004" <pbyrd at m...>
wrote:
> Voldy (in Quirrel) was at Hogwarts with Snape (not too quick are you 
> DD?).  He heard Snape threaten Quirrel about the stone.  LV knows 
> Snape is a traitor, right? 

He has to. Even if LV "joined" Quirrel late in the game (I don't think
so) he was absolutely there when Quirrel confronted Harry. 
> 
> So Snape is the death eater who "one is a traitor, and certainly will 
> die"-LV in GoF.  Right?

Just about has to be, no?  In the Muggle world, or any world that
makes sense, Snape is completely "blown" and could never "go
operational" again.  The only possibility for Snape to be of any use
as an agent is that he's turned a DE into a double agent, and that DE
had better hope his Occlumency is up to snuff.  My vote? Narcissa, who
might play both sides of the fence between Lucius and the Good Side
because of Draco.

Maybe JKR never read John LeCarre.

> 
> Bet he dies protecting Harry, fulfilling the debt to James.

Very possible. As much as Snape hates Harry, he's always done his duty
to the Order.  If only he'd do his duty as a teacher, he'd be a little
more likable.

Jim Ferer





More information about the HPforGrownups archive