Sneakoscope question

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 96100

> SB4E:
> 
> I'm going to play devil's advocate here, but what if the fact that 
we suspect Scabbers/Pettigrew is the real red herring....JKR 
may have written the scene to lead us to believe by the end of 
POA that it was going off in the train because of Scabbers being 
Pettigrew who had been the real secret keeper...but what if...and 
this pulls together several posts on other topics and the theory 
that Sirius wasn't killed by Bellatrix...what if the sneakoscope 
really was going off in response to Lupin...(for the record, don't
try 
to kill me...I hope this is totally off base, but...)
> 

Ah...nice to welcome another ESE!Lupin theorist to the list.  :) 
Possibly Lupin was genuinely asleep at first but woke up during 
the conversation. Maybe he then pretended he was still asleep 
and that's what set the sneak-o-scope off.

Pippin
whose original Ever-so-evil Lupin post is 39362