Reparo
laylalast
liliana at worldonline.nl
Fri Apr 16 22:24:10 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 96166
> Jem wrote:
> If Harry's glasses could be repaired by Reparo (CoS), and the
> glass door to the train compartment could be repaired by Reparo
> (GoF), why couldn't Ron's wand be repaired (CoS) or Ginny's book
> of herbs (GoF)? Both attempted a repair with Spellotape.
Lilian:
As I see it, Reparo is used to repair something that has (just) been
broken. Also, the things that are broken are not magical by
themselves.
Ron's wand is broken in CoS, yes, but it was already much worn by
usage (unicorn's hair sticking out in PS/SS). Most likely the final
straw. Apart from that, a wand contains a magical substance. IMO,
Reparo is most likely not a sufficient spell to repair somehing
powerful like that.
Ginny's book is not so much damaged, but worn.
So, Reparo (repair) if you break something not magical. Spellotape
if it's worn. And the dust bin at the end of everything! :-)
Just my thoughts.
Lilian
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive