Snape, Lupin, and the map

[Kathy King]

No: HPFGUIDX 96184

Lilian wrote:
My guess is the same as yours, Snape did at least suspect that the
map used to belong to MWPP, maybe not because of the nicknames but
because of the insults the map threw at him - reminded him of
insults in his Hogwarts years?

vmonte responds:
Snape knows all of their nicknames! In Snape's penseive memories
James and gang are all calling each other by their nicknames...


Kathy's thought's

I dont think that Snape heard what Harry did and therefore does not know 
the nicknames.

It must depend on your conception of the penceive. I feel that the person 
entering the memory can explore beyond the boundaries of its originator. 
Harry felt that he may not be able to follow his dad and friends if Snape 
chose a different coarse. Harry felt as though as long as he kept Snape 
insight he would be able to hear what went on with his dad. This didnt 
actually mean (to me) that Snape heard everything that Harry heard, only 
those parts which contained Snapes physical self-being in actual ear range. 
Snape didnt appear to be alarmed by anything that was said until it was 
directed to him. Snape appeared to be going on with what he was doing not 
paying a bit of attention to the Fab. Four.
I defiantly could be wrong, but that is how I always foresaw the penceives 
propertys.



Kathy

_________________________________________________________________
>From must-see cities to the best beaches, plan a getaway with the Spring 
Travel Guide! http://special.msn.com/local/springtravel.armx