Where did Snape go Was: Trelawney and Ignorance

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Mon Apr 19 14:56:48 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 96389

snip
> 
> > Potioncat wrote:
> > And another missing moment.  Back in CoS, Quirrell says that 
Snape 
> > watched him closely.  So why didn't Snape know that Quirrell was 
in 
> > the Chamber? or at least that both Quirrell and the trio were 
> > unaccounted for?
> > 
> 
> Lilian:
> 
> Erm ... don't mean to offend, but ... aren't you mixing things up 
a 
> bit? Quirrell and the Chamber?
> 
> Anyway, in PS/SS Snape did try to keep a close watch on the trio, 
but 
> they went of in the dead of night, from their dormitory, covered 
by 
> the invisibility cloak. If Snape was anywhere around, patrolling, 
he 
> would have assumed that the trio was in their beds as well as 
> Quirrell. Snape has no legitimate right to enter Gryffindor tower, 
> nor Quirrell's private quarters. 
> But then again, he may have tried to alert DD, who later said 
> (paraphrasing from memory): 'When I arrived at the MoM, I found 
that 
> I should be at Hogwarts'. Urgent message waiting for him?
> 
x

Potioncat:
Oops, my mistake.  Yes, I intended to say when they went after the 
stone, I keep thinking of that as a chamber as well.  Then of course 
there are all those chamber pots in the room of requirements.

You may have a good point.  I may have some movie contamination 
about time of day.  I'll re-read that as well.
Potioncat





More information about the HPforGrownups archive