Was Harry Alone?

[cubfanbudwoman]

No: HPFGUIDX 96525

Bonny wrote:
> I have come across some evidence that Harry may not have been 
> alone when he cast the patronus across the lake in PoA, and I was 
> wondering  what others thought.
> 
> In canon, Harry is (presumably) alone by the lake-side (though it 
> is never stated that he was certainly alone, simply no one else is 
> mentioned as being percieved), Hermione being in Hagrids hut. 
> There has, however, been some evidence to the contrary - one of 
> the things that JKR has "hidden" inside the books that she cannot 
> avoid displaying, not matter how subtley, in the films 
> ((suggestion - look over Harry's shoulder, to the right side of 
> the screen, in the PoA trailer - there is distinctly someone 
> there)). 
> 
> I apoligize because I know this is bordering very dangerously on 
> movie contamination, but it is tied in so closley with the canon 
> and predicting what will happen therin that I really couldn't help 
> myself!



Siriusly Snapey Susan:
Bonny, could you go ahead & mention the things you saw in canon 
which seem to indicate someone else was there?  (Yes, I saw a person 
[I assumed it was Sirius] in the movie trailer, but I didn't figure 
that meant anything other than an indication of who Harry was 
protecting when he cast expecto patronum.)  I don't recall anything 
in canon which suggests another person was there.  Please share!

Siriusly Snapey Susan