Conspiracy Theories

[vmonte]

No: HPFGUIDX 96665

I (vmonte) wrote:
I also don't like the way Lupin reacts during the penseive scene. It
seems obvious that he doesn't like what the Potter gang are doing to
Snape, yet he does nothing to stop it (I realize that he was a child
in this scene).

I also think that it's likely that Lupin was secretly in love with
Lily. Perhaps his feelings of guilt are wrapped around this issue.


vmonte again:
I just want to clarify my earlier post. I think that out of all of 
James's high school friends, Lupin is the only character that has 
matured emotionally.  I like Lupin, I just think that he may be 
feeling bad about something he did in his youth. 

There is a scene in one of the books where Snape tells Harry 
(something to the effect of) that people who wear their emotions on 
their sleeve are weak. Well I think that Lupin, more so than Snape, 
really keeps his emotions in check.