Conspiracy Theories

[vmonte]

No: HPFGUIDX 96682

Melanie wrote:
I just wanted to say you are leaving out my favorite type of betrayal 
theories: The non informed betrayal. The person that thinks they are 
doing the right thing but ends up doing something terrible. That 
person is Molly Weasley. Suppose, she is asked to give information 
out, in exachange for the safety of her family and possibly
Harry. Suppose, she for instance is only asked to give info on 
Hermione (being a muggle born they may want her gone..for she is the 
worst kind of muggle born. A muggle born that is smarter than most 
other purebloods). It might be a stretch but we are given an awful 
lot of clues into Molly's personality. Her ability to believe with 
little proof (aka witch weekly article about Hermione and Harry). Her 
semi-dislike of Hermione, it doesn't seem that she bonds with her as 
much as Harry. We know that their are times that she lets her fear 
get in the way of practicality. All of this does not mean that she 
will turn away but JKR has given us ample clues and I don't those
clues are without meaning

vmonte responds:
I don't think that Molly is going to do anything terrible. In fact, I 
think that she will probably die saving one of her children (probably 
Percy).  Anyway, my vote for someone who "thinks that they are doing 
something right but ends up doing something terrible" goes to: 
Lupin.  He is more of an enigma to me than Snape.  He knows or has 
done something that he hasn't shared with Dumbledore.