Conspiracy Theories

[fanofminerva]

No: HPFGUIDX 96707

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "cubfanbudwoman" 
<susiequsie23 at s...> wrote:
>  Miss Melanie <ms_melanie1999 at y...> wrote:
> ... my favorite type of betrayal theories: The non informed 
> betrayal.  The person that thinks theya re doing the right thing 
but 
> ends up doing something terrible.  That person is Molly Weasley.  
> Suppose, she is asked to give information out, in exachange for 
the 
> safety of her family and possibly Harry.  Suppose, she for 
instance 
> is only asked to give infor on Hermione (being a muggle born they 
may 
> want her gone..for she is the worst kind of muggle born.  A muggle 
> born that is smarter than most other purebloods).  It might be a 
> stretch but we are given an awful lot of clues into Molly's 
> personality.  Her ability to believe with little proof (aka witch 
> weekly
> >  article about Hermione and Harry).  Her semi-dislike of 
Hermione, 
> it doesn't seem that she bonds with her as much as Harry.  We know 
> that their are times that she lets her fear get in the way of 
> practicality.  All of this does not mean that she will turn away 
but 
> JKR has given us ample clues and I don't those clues are without 
> meaning
> 
> 
> Siriusly Snapey Susan:
> Not trying to stir the pot too much, but this isn't the first time 
> I've seen this possibility attached to Molly.  My question is, are 
we 
> really so sure Molly is susceptible to this any more than any 
other 
> character...say, ARTHUR Weasley?  Is there canon evidence to 
suggest 
> that *Mr.* Weasley would not be susceptible to the temptation to 
give 
> information in exchange for the life of someone he loves, but that 
> Molly would be?  
> 
> I know we see Molly's fears when she's trying to handle the 
boggart 
> at 12 GP, but is there really any reason to think she would fail 
the 
> Order in this way and someone else *would not*?
> 
> In all honestly, I think any number of people could fall into 
> that "trap".  *Anyone* who cares deeply about another person--
Harry 
> for Ron, Molly for Arthur, Arthur for Fred, Lupin for Harry--is 
> potentially susceptible to this kind of thing.
> 
> Just had to get that off my chest.
> Siriusly Snapey Susan

It seems like this already has happened...Harry for Sirius