Harry and wandless magic

[arrowsmithbt]

No: HPFGUIDX 96786

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "earendil_fr" <viviane at l...> wrote:
> > Owlery2003 comments:
> > What about Lupin on the train when he conjures a handful of 
> > whatever? Of course, he might have used his wand for this, but 
> > there's no mention of it . . . 
> 
> Earendil:
> I checked this scene. I suppose you're refering to the moment in the 
> train when Lupin gives chocolate to the children.
> There's no mention of conjuring. The children are discussing the 
> Dementor and Harry's passing out, until they jump when they hear 
> Lupin breaking a bar of chocolate into bits. For all we know he 
> could have taken the chocolate from his pocket or bag.
> (sorry, can't quote, I only own a French version of PoA, but it's 
> midway through chapter 5)
> 

Erm, it's before that, I think.
When the lights go out Lupin conjures up a handful of flames.
It''s only when the Dementor refuses to leave that he resorts to his wand.

Kneasy