DD: an appreciation plus Lupin - again.

[tapairuparauri]

No: HPFGUIDX 97006

Kneasy:
>  What if the voice Harry hears was not James, James having being 
> caught by surprise and already dead. Suppose it was Lupin's voice? 
> This would neatly explain his "in a strange voice", because he 
*knows*
> that it wasn't James.
> 
> I have in the past suggested that Sirius suffered from 'survivors
> guilt'; maybe Lupin does too. He feels a responsibility for the
> deaths of James and Lily. He survived because Voldy went for his
> prime targets first; Lupin would be dealt  with later. But he didn't
> last long enough to get round to him.

Jetamors:
Nah.  The family was under the Fidelius Charm at that time, so if 
Lupin had been there then he would've known that Peter was the Secret 
Keeper.  Also, with Sirius distrusting Remus it would have been 
stupid to let Remus be one of the people allowed access to them.  I'm 
guessing the only people who had access to the Potters (before Peter 
broke the Charm) were Peter and possibly Sirius; remember, even 
Dumbledore didn't know about the switchup, so he couldn't reach them 
either.

The other question is what on earth happened to Lupin if he was 
there?  Why would he run away from the scene if baby Harry was still 
there?  And why didn't he hunt down Peter like Sirius did?