Siriusly Alive ...or Gone but not forgotten

[vmonte]

No: HPFGUIDX 97241

JimLaming wrote:

I think this is one of those times when an apple really is an apple.
Every indication is that Sirius is dead and cannot come back to this
life. HOWEVER, look at the room, The Death Chamber. What if this
amphitheater like room, is like a stage where the dead and the living
can communicate? Somewhere in this thread, someone indicates that
perhaps you have to have someone on that side of the veil to hear the
voices. If you can hear the voices, what if the person on the other
side can come to the doorway (stone Archway hung with a black veil)
and converse with you? Sirius is gone but never forgotten....

What do you think?


vmonte responds:

You may be right! What really bothers me about the veil is that Harry 
thought he heard Ron's voice in it.  I hope this is not foreshadowing!