Was Harry in Danger from the Basilisk?
Josh Warren
wjwarren4269 at comcast.net
Wed Aug 4 01:33:36 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 108748
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Cathy Drolet" <cldrolet at s...>
wrote:
> DuffyPoo:
>
> Could it not have been possible for Salazar Slytherin, the 'twisted
old loony,' to put a spell on the snake to make it able to
distinguish between Muggle and magic? Just another thought.
Well, owls and thestrals have no problems identifying locations of
people and places, respectively. With or without spellwork, the
possibility for the baselisk to distinguish individuals is certainly
an easy reach. Even Marauder's Map-esque senses could have been
spelled (thus avoiding Snape and Filch while hunting).
Keep in mind that the blinded beast didn't mistakenly attack TMR in
the chamber, and neither TMR nor Ginny were ever accidently killed or
petrified while commanding it.
Overall I still believe that the attacks were directed (perhaps not
at Hermione, the cat, or Sir Nick intentionally), as Justin, Colin,
and (I beleive) Penelope were all people whom Harry might want to
target if he were the Heir. Remember that TMR quickly determined that
he wanted to meet Harry, and that attacks could have been designed
specifically to push him away from the general populace to help
encourage an opportunity.
Josh
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive