Shared thoughts

[snow15145]

No: HPFGUIDX 108757

Meidbh replies:
>snip<

And for the first prophecy...
I said it before but the logic and grammar are only correct for two
people /personae /entities in the prophecy. For three it just
doesn't work! (The post is 108241).

Snow:

I looked back to the post you referenced and remember reading it. 
Little snip from your post 108241:

"If the "other" is a third peson then the final part of the prophecy
should read "both must die at the hand of the other for neither can
live while the other survives"."
 
This is a correct statement that a third person should be named in 
such a way in the prophecy but what I am implying is that both people 
involved, Voldemort and Harry, share "the other" (Tom Riddle) which 
would fit into the original prophecy. Only one can survive! Who ever 
wins the golden prize (Tom Riddle) and either reconnects with Tom 
Riddle or destroys Tom Riddle is the big winner.

Snow