The Recurring Challenges (Was Re: To Where To When )

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 108923

> Valky 
> 
> "1 Who broke into Gringotts in PS/SS and attempted to take the 
Stone. 
> 
> DuffyPoo:
Quirrell is the one who broke into Gringotts because he says 
so, "When I failed to steal the stone from Gringotts, he (LV) was 
most displeased." No one 'foiled' them. Quirrel got in, opened the 
vault (Dark Magic, Quirrell is the DADA teacher after all), found 
the stone gone and left.  What the Goblins had to go on was the open 
vault or some Dark Wizard Catcher device going off - a sneakoscope 
perhaps? 
>

Valky Now:

Ahh yes of course, Thankyou Duffy I had forgotten Quirrels 
confession. 

Incedentally I had been thinking about this myself and I wonder if 
someone with Goblin Blood was actually involved in the attempted 
robbery. But thats entirely something different.

I still wonder anyway about the goings on in London in PS/SS but 
most of my argument is put to bed here in your post so I guess 
Timeturning isnt it. 

I must confess that I had ulterior theories to feed in to this one 
if it had come back surviving. Which it didn't, but I would still 
like to put them up for scrutiny.

The three recurring challenges (AKA my absolute sure bet prediction 
for the finale of the series):

1. Harry Flies Masterfully. As seen in the Key obstacle PS/SS, and 
the First Task GOF.
2. The Martyr. As seen in the Chess Game PS/SS, Hermiones most 
important Clue to the monster COS, and by Harry saving *everyone* in 
the second task GOF.
3. The Maze of Puzzles and Surprises: As seen in the final two 
obstacles PS/SS, The Final Task GOF and the Whomping Willow 
Timeturning sequence in POA.

You might guess that Gringotts/London in PS/SS was my first pick for 
Harry Flies Masterfully. Now its back to the drawing board for all 
three.

Best to You Duffy
from Valky