Marauder's Map, the Marauders, and Voldemort

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 109026


 
> RMM:
> > Black believed Lupin was spying for Voldemort!!!  Why would he 
> unless 
> > he knew Lupin was involved with Voldemort in some fashion??
> 
> 
> 
> Alla:
> 
> 
> That is a VERY INTERESTING question. We all want to know what 
caused 
> Sirius to doubt Lupin and vice versa. 

Potioncat:
RMM whether anyone turns out to agree with you, you've brought up a 
whole new way of looking at this. :-)

I do think the logic above is circular.  To think Black must have 
suspected Lupin because Lupin had known LV...

Rather I think the Order knew there was a spy in their midst and had 
been for about a year. We know it had become a suspicious time.  So, 
Lupin had suspected Black had gone to LV.  Black thought Lupin  had 
gone to LV.  But, actually neither one had.

...now however, if you believe in ESE!Black or ESE!Lupin, that 
changes  the picture!

Potioncat who really needs to stop now.