DD knows where they are
snow15145
snow15145 at yahoo.com
Fri Aug 6 00:45:54 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 109070
Aggie:
This comment of yours made me wonder if DD had one of those clocks
like the
Weasley's. He could 'programme' it to show whoever he liked.
Once I started writing this though, I was hit by an inspirational
bolt of
lightening!! What about his *watch*? It is mentioned several times
and it is
never explained how it works, AND it's on JKR's web site (when Peeves
comes)!!
OOOH I'm all excited! I've had a brainwave! (It doesn't happen very
often!)
I'm sure that this has been discussed thousands of times and someone
will be
along shortly and burst my bubble!!
IMO it would solve some of the mysteries as how DD KNOWS so much. He
has a
list, (12 hands I do believe the watch has) of the 12 people he wants
to keep
tabs on and then he just has to look at his watch to know where they
are.
It would explain how he knew he should be a Hogwarts in PS/SS, and
how he knew
to be early at Harry's hearing in OotP and I'm sure there are loads
of other
times that this would explain, WITHOUT reverting to Time Travel!
Who do you think the 12 are?
Any thoughts on this?
Snow:
I like your idea Aggie! Dumbledore even comments about how much he
likes Molly's fascinating clock. As for the twelve people he watches
over, I can think of a few right off.
Clock Hands and excuse as to why they were "chosen":
1st-Harry (of course)
2nd-Fudge (keep your friends close but your enemies closer)
3rd and 4th- James and Lily Potter (at least at some point they were,
that's how he possibly knew about the attack)
5th-Neville (how else did Dumbledore know that he was brave against
his friends? Specifically Harry)
6th-Ron (same applies to Ron, how did DD know about the sacrifice of
Ron's chess piece? Also that he is Harry's best friend)
7th-Hermione (again DD knows about Hermione's knowledge of Herbology
and I suspect talks to her in a double talk manner in his speeches so
that she can enlighten her best friend Harry)
8th- Lucius Malfoy (DD pretty much telling Lucius I know you got more
stuff like the diary at home, if you do it again there will be
consequences)
9th-? (someone who either was friend or foe to Harry and the quest)
10th-? (ditto to no. 9)
11th-Tom Riddle/Voldemort (how else would DD have concluded that
Riddle was Voldemort?)
12th-Snape (this one I saved specifically for twelve o'clock! Over
Harry or Riddle/Voldemort because he spies on both Harry and
Voldemort for DD. Snape was spying on what Voldemort was doing
through his occlumency teaching with Harry. Snape's hesitation in
answering Harry's question of "I guess that's your job, to spy, is
it" can possibly construed as well yes in a way I am spying on
Voldemort through you silly boy)
My question to you Aggie is what possible perils or safe zones (like
Weasley's clock
at home, at work, in mortal danger) appear on the
watch?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive