Harry's Patronus (was Re: To Where To When)

kempermentor kempermentor at yahoo.com
Sat Aug 7 08:34:46 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 109250

DuffyPoo wrote:
 
>> ...Again, he was, when he cast the Patronus, in no real danger of 
being attacked by Dementors. They were on the other side of the lake 
with Sirius and his other self. << 

vmonte responded:
 
> I disagree. Harry was in danger of dying during the PoA attack. He 
was saving himself remember? How many Dementors were by that lake? 
<snip> If I'm not mistaken 13 year old Harry saved Sirius, who was 
also an accomplished wizard. <


Kemper responds:

I can see your point, Vivian.  But, and though I don't have my books 
in front of me, Sirius doesn't have his own wand and hasn't used 
magic in forever, being locked up for 12 years.  Not only that but he 
isn't well nourished to be getting it on with more than a few 
dementors.  Harry is well fed and has been doing magic rather 
regularly over the past 3 years, has his own wand and has been 
practicing that particular spell for some time.  






More information about the HPforGrownups archive