Harry's Patronus (was Re: To Where To When)

nkafkafi nkafkafi at yahoo.com
Sat Aug 7 14:53:49 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 109267


> DuffyPoo:
> We must remember there were two Harrys present that night. One on 
each side of the lake.  The one who truly conjured the Patronus was 
in no danger from the Dementors, as they were all on the other side 
of the lake with the 'other' Harry and Sirius.  (Man I hate TT.)    
<snip>

Neri:
Actually it is the other way around. The Harry who is attacked by the 
Dementors is in no danger at all (or at least not from the point-of 
view of the other Harry, if he would have only thought it through). 
This is because at this time we know that this Harry was already 
saved. The Harry who casts the Patronus, OTOH, is certainly in 
danger, since nothing is known about HIS future. Who's to say that 
there isn't a second gang of dementors sneaking behind him at the 
very moment?

Neri, who likes TT when it's done right.    






More information about the HPforGrownups archive