Umbridge is Nagini...Long

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 109673

Snow <snow15145 at y...> wrote:
> Umbridge is Nagini Theory based on suggestive canon
> 

I simply do not think so...if Umbridge is Nagini...then why have 
Malfoy there plying Fudge with his gold? (We know Voldemort can 
possess people...why not Percy? I think Umbridge is nasty enough on 
her own.  If Fudge was not such a fool, it may be neccessary, but I 
do not think so.

I think Umbridge is in OOP for quite a few reasons.

1. That not everyone is either in the OOP or a DE.

2. To show how Sirius' parents thought Voldemort "had the right 
idea", but of course went the wrong way about it. (Probably 
especially thought this after their son died.

3. To show how prejudice against "non" or "half" human creatures 
affect the characters and those around them. (I can really see 
Umbridge trying to force through regulation guidelines on Phoenixes).

4. To show HOW some people attempt to discredit those who disagree. 
She wouldn't kill Harry herself, but would send dementors to do 
it...in all honesty, I can see her previously trying to send a 
werewolf to "do Harry in"...but not succeeding hence, the anti-
werewolf legislation.

And lastly

5. Nagini would never complain about nifflers in her office...she'd 
probably eat them and dash out to eat the poor soul(s) who had been 
levitating them through her window.

Umbridge is a control freak who thinks that she can prevent 
Voldemort's return or fear thereof through legislation and punishment 
of those around her who do not share her views.

It also gives us yet another excuse why Dumbledore must remain so 
much distant...too much control ruins a good plan. (Can you imagine 
what would have happened if Umbridge just spied and actually taught 
defense against the dark arts?)

Doddiemoemoe
(who'd probably have Umbridge doing lines with a quill that would 
permanently tatoo the back of her hand; which makes me wonder what 
the centars did to her....)