Umbridge is Nagini...Long

[Brenda M.]

No: HPFGUIDX 109677

>>> Snow wrote:
> Umbridge is Nagini; 
> Umbridge is very snake-like in her attitude, which would be best 
represented by a snake animagus figure.  What if when Bertha went 
missing and the Ministry were attempting to track her whereabouts, 
Umbridge was sent to Albania? [snip]
> Umbridge is most willing to give to Malfoy anything he wants since 
he has managed to secure a prestigious seat at the Ministry for her. 
[snip]
> Umbridge's office fireplace is the only one the Ministry is not 
> checking ... Now, how could a snake of enormous proportion find 
its way into the Ministry and out again without detection the night 
Mr. Weasley was attacked? Simple it was Umbridge! [snip]
[snipping rest of very interesting post] <<<


Brenda now:

Hiya Snow!

You have certainly presented your case strongly IMO.  Given what you 
have found in canon, no I don't believe it is too far-fetched.  It 
sounds very plausible.

There is just tiny part of me that makes me not want to believe it, 
and it is Sirius' remark in GoF, paraphrased as "the world is not 
divided into good people and the Death Eaters".  Sure, she is foul 
and devious, but that is not to say she is part of the evil cult.  
Just a nasty politician, lol.  Since Fudge will not be serving this 
purpose (me a firm believer of Fudge as the 'one who has left me'... 
that's another thread) Umbridge is the perfect candidate.  A power-
hungry stumpy accessorized woman, lol.

Brenda