Umbridge is Nagini...Long

snow15145 snow15145 at yahoo.com
Wed Aug 11 12:08:27 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 109692

Doddiemoemoe's reply to my previous post:

I simply do not think so...if Umbridge is Nagini...then why have
Malfoy there plying Fudge with his gold? (We know Voldemort can
possess people...why not Percy? I think Umbridge is nasty enough on
her own. If Fudge was not such a fool, it may be neccessary, but I
do not think so. >snip<

AND

Brenda's reply:

There is just tiny part of me that makes me not want to believe it,
and it is Sirius' remark in GoF, paraphrased as "the world is not
divided into good people and the Death Eaters". Sure, she is foul
and devious, but that is not to say she is part of the evil cult.
Just a nasty politician, lol. Since Fudge will not be serving this
purpose (me a firm believer of Fudge as the 'one who has left me'...
that's another thread) Umbridge is the perfect candidate. A power-
hungry stumpy accessorized woman, lol.


Snow replying to both posts:

I didn't mean to imply in any way that Umbridge was a willing 
participant of Voldemort any more than Bertha, Bodes or Ginny were. 
In fact it would be more along the lines of what Ginny had done for 
Riddle but didn't remember having done anything. There is defiantly a 
possession issue where Umbridge is concerned in this theory. 
Pettigrew controlled this possession factor at first by forcing her 
into her animagus figure to be of use to Voldemort in regaining his 
strength through the snake's venom. Malfoy took over after 
Voldemort's bodily return to ensure her a position both at Hogwarts 
and the Ministry where she could be of use for Voldemort to obtain 
information and entry. Malfoy's job was to prime the candidate 
(Umbridge) using the imperius curse for possession by Voldemort when 
it became necessary to obtain entrance to the Ministry undetected. 

Umbridge's fireplace in her office can be used both ways, to get into 
the Ministry or have someone from the Ministry come into her office. 
Umbridge trusts Malfoy and would allow him entry to her office 
wherein he could put the imperius curse on her, with ease, for 
Voldemort's possession. I would imagine that it would be easier for 
Voldemort to possess Umbridge in snake form because she would be 
easier to control. 

Umbridge acts on her own accord when she is in human form, which may 
be why she is such a suitable candidate, it wouldn't take much effort 
to condition her for control by Voldemort. 

Umbridge is less than talented when it comes to magic. Umbridge 
couldn't even vanquish the Weasley twins' portable swamp that 
Flitwick managed to do with ease. Umbridge was unable to control the 
situation with the fireworks that again, Flitwick announced he could 
have done easily but didn't know if he had the authority to. Umbridge 
is anything but a powerful witch so how did she obtain a top ranking 
position at the Ministry, and why?  













More information about the HPforGrownups archive