biggest SPOILER _ graveyard at Hogwarts

aboutthe1910s aboutthe1910s at yahoo.com
Wed Aug 11 16:16:39 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 109712

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "arielock2001" <arielock at a...>
wrote:
<snip>
> Born as the seventh month dies:
> September is "the seventh month." That is what the word
> means. It just can't be July.
<snip>


I hate to bring this up when you have put forth a theory that you have
clearly put a lot of thought and care into, but here's the *really*
huge flaw--see it *just can* be July.  And while I know Jo loves to
turn things around on us, and I don't believe that she would allow
*convention* to dictate plot, I still just cannot believe that she
would write a book in which the main antagonist is defeated by someone
other than the protagonist.  And, quite simply, Harry is the
protagonist.  Not Lily.  Not Peter.  And, while I'm expounding, *not
Hermione*!

All this said, one can never know all that Jo has in mind until one
has read the seventh book.  So, while I can't buy this theory, I
wouldn't say that it is *impossible*, only improbable.  In any case,
you put forth a really nice theory.  Thanks : )

aboutthe1910s





More information about the HPforGrownups archive