Lupin's Age/Whomping Willow
Bex
hubbarrk at rose-hulman.edu
Wed Aug 11 18:02:02 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 109727
Chris wrote:
> Also JKR constantly refers to him looking old and tired, now where
as
> this is mostly to do with his lythancopy, if he was 11 when he went
> to Hogwarts he would only be 34/35 in PoA, which is not very old
for
> a wizard surely. Considering that Wizards supposedly live longer
than
> Muggles.
Yb comments:
JKR has stated that Wizards have a considerably longer lifespan than
muggles (DD is ~150!). I think Lupin looks old and ragged due
to "that time of the month" plus the fact that he can't find a steady
job and this Harry/Order business is really taking a toll on him.
My thoughts on the Whomping Willow:
Who said it was a sapling when it was planted? In fact, it /couldn't/
have been! How would it keep the other students away from the
entrance to the tunnel? It had to be full grown, so it may have been
40-50 years old when it was planted.
~Yb
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive