Case for Marauders (was Re: Marauders, Voldemort and the Map)

[ohneill_2001]

No: HPFGUIDX 109983

> > Valky:
> > And the finality of that statement is Nothing Will preclude that 
> > James would practise Dark Arts short of it being entirely absent 
> > from his total and comprehensive history laid out before us.
> > At the very least canon that he hated it doesnt demand so much 
> > history to be given to truth that he wouldn't perform it 
conciously 
> > and wilfully. Much like you wouldn't wilfully eat oranges if you 
> > Hated them.
> 
> RMM:
> And some people have occupations that they hate but perform 
willingly 
> and consciously.

Now Cory:

There is a world of difference between performing a job that 
you "hate" (out of a need to earn a livlihood, or for whatever 
reason), and becoming a DE even though you hate the Dark Arts.  If a 
person sincerely believes that killing is morally wrong, he is not 
going to become a professional hitman, no matter what the 
incentives.  Are you seriously trying to equate that (or becoming a 
DE even though you hate the Dark Arts) with getting out of bed every 
day to go to a 9-to-5 job that you hate?

--Cory