How long were Voldemort and Quirrell "together"?
Erin
erinellii at yahoo.com
Sat Aug 14 05:51:34 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 110028
Neri wrote:
> I'm not sure from your post if you fully realize it, but <snip>: In
the beginning of the SS/PS year, when Harry meets Quirrell in The
Leaky Cauldron, Quirrell is not possessed yet.
Erin:
Yes, I do realize it, sorry that wasn't clear enough in my previous
post!
Neri:
So Voldy could be "with" Quirrell for more than a year before SS/PS,
but he wasn't possessing him at that time. He only possessed him from
the beginning of the school year in SS/PS
Erin:
Exactly. This is the point that I was trying to make, that Vapormort
could have been hiding out at Quirrell's place for quite a while
before joining Quirrell inside his head. (Incidently, where does
one store a disembodied evil overlord? In the linen closet? Under
the bed? If Quirrell, like all the other teachers to date, had
lodgings at Hogwarts was Vapormort right there under Dumbledore's
nose? The mind boggles.)
This extra time between the Albanian pick-up and the possession was
what allowed Quirrell to perfect his fearful, stuttering act and what
allowed everyone around him to get used to the new Quirrell. We see
that "everyone"-- all the students-- already has an explanation for
why Quirrell's classroom smells of garlic, but only the twins are
commenting on the new factor; the turban.
Now, you also brought up Hagrid's comments in CoS about the jinx
making it difficult to find anyone for the DADA job and how no one
has lasted long in the position. Another poster, Brenda, spotted the
same thing:
Neri wrote:
> When Hagrid says this he doesn't mean Lockhart, who has only just
> started. So he must be including Quirrell as one (but not the only)
> who didn't last for long.
Brenda wrote:
Assuming your logic is correct, then it must be only recently that
the DADA job got its reputation of 'jinxed'. The word spread pretty
fast though, seeing how Lockhart was the only applicant for the job.
Erin:
Never fear, I have an explanation for this also! Let's go with the
four-year model again.
Year 1: Quirrell's first year of teaching, the year he is fine
while "studyin' outta books" according to Hagrid. Suppose, however
that there was an incident near the end of the year, a nasty incident
(perhaps involving a Dark Creature) that convinces Quirrell he needs
to travel in order to get some firsthand experience. That would be
viewed as a part of the jinx.
Year 2: Quirrell is traveling, and there's a substitute DADA
teacher. (S)he comes to a sticky end. That's viewed as part of the
jinx.
Year 3: Quirrell returns, only now he's "scared of the students,
scared of his own subject". He trembles and stutters all the time.
His new fearfulness is viewed as part of the jinx.
Year 4: Quirrell dies when Voldemort leaves his body. This, of
course, is viewed as part of the... ah well, you get the idea.
Even if you reject the year one incident (pure speculation, there's
no canon for it), I'd think years two through four would be enough to
get the idea of a jinx going.
---Erin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive