Why didn't the Longbottoms go into hiding?

Brenda M. Agent_Maxine_is at hotmail.com
Thu Aug 19 05:07:47 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 110576

>>> NHR wrote: 
> After Proffessor Trelawny's prediction in the Hog's Head, why 
> did only the Potter's go into hiding and not also the Longbottoms? 
<<<


Brenda:

Well we don't know for certain whether the Longbottoms went into 
hiding or not, do we? We only know that Frank and Alice were 
tortured by Bella & co after Voldemort's disappearance.

Why they were tortured bothers me though. I think the explanation we 
are given in the book was that they were tortured for information 
related to Voldemort's whereabout or some nonsense like that.

No, I personally think they had Neville in protection and that's why 
Frank and Alice were tortured -- DEs wanted to find Neville in the 
hopes to use the other prophecy boy to restore Voldemort. I don't 
think permanently driving them to insanity was in Bella's agenda, it 
wouldn't have done them any good. I can think of a scenario where 
Frank and Alice egged them on ('did you know, your Dark Lord has 
been vanquished by an infant boy') and Bella finally lost it there.

Brenda





More information about the HPforGrownups archive