Why didn't the Longbottoms go into hiding?

humantupperware1 humantupperware1 at yahoo.com.au
Thu Aug 19 10:10:57 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 110613

nearlyheadlessryan <nearlyheadlessryan at y...> wrote:
> After Professor Trelawney's prediction in the Hog's Head, why did 
> only the Potters go into hiding and not also the Longbottoms? At 
> this point Dumbledore would have only been able to deduce that it 
> was EITHER Harry or Neville and would not have known that it was 
> definitely Harry. So I will ask it again: Why, then, didn't Frank 
> and Alice Longbottom not go into hiding as well? Were they not 
> warned for some reason as, clearly, the Potters were? Maybe then 
> Frank and Alice wouldn't be veggies. Anyone that has any ideas I 
> would love to hear them. 


HumanTupperware:

This is an interesting point for me for two reasons........first, do we 
know for sure that Frank and Alice didn't go into hiding? We don't know 
that much about Neville's history, and I get the feeling that we'll hear 
more about that to come in the new books.......What we do know though, is 
that it was the Lestranges who tortured the Longbottoms, which begs the questions: Why weren't Frank and Alice killed? And why did Neville escape unharmed? And if Voldy knew that it was one boy or the other that was to 
prove his downfall, why send deatheaters to the Longbottoms and go to the Potters himself? Or did the Lestranges only go to the Longbottoms after 
Voldy was vanquished, which might mean that Voldy was going to go and kill Neville after he had killed Harry, but never made it there?

Sorry to answer your question with more questions, but I think all of this 
comes under the myterious missing 24 hours, which I assume will be 
explained further in the new books......nevertheless, I am curious.....

hmmmmm?  

HumanTupperware






More information about the HPforGrownups archive