The Portkey Cup (WAS: Apparation and Sirius' vault)

mrs_sonofgib tinainfay at msn.com
Thu Aug 19 11:34:43 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 110650

> 
> 
> Linda:
> I have always thought that DD or the MoM made the TWcup a Portkey 
to 
> return the winner to the entrance to the maze. It seems to me that 
> it wouldn't have been common knowledge. The portkey could have 
been 
> magicked to only transfer one of the four champions, thus not 
having 
> an effect on the fake Moody. 


That does make sense.  Once you've won the tournament, they couldn't 
expect you to make your way back out again - that would be stupid.  
(what if you ran into another competitor and there was a fight over 
the trophy etc).  So you grab it, you've won and now you are back in 
front of the entire school.  Perfect sense.  

So Moody added a stop at the graveyard.  He would have thought 
possibly that was the only stop. OR Possibly he could have known 
that about it's original use (taking the winner to the front of the 
maze) but supposed it wouldn't matter because Harry would be dead 
and unable to use it.

Thanks, Linda!  That's my theory and I'm sticking to it!
~tina






More information about the HPforGrownups archive