Who stuns Sirius -- ESE!Lupin?

[cdayr]

No: HPFGUIDX 111105


> Brenda:
 
> Err... I must agree with Alla and Dzeytoun with this one, 
Dumbledore 
> will face far greater difficulty in getting Harry ready for the war 
> if he had caused such a heart-wrecking loss to Harry.

CDR again:

Ouch.
However, the arguments you all have offered in return for my 
bizarro theory have been entirely convincing- I yield to the 
Dumbledore would never do that theory. I didn't want to believe it 
anyway, and only was obsessed with it today, so I will easily 
shelve it with my many other out-there thoughts.

I still feel the actual situation in the Chamber is very ambiguous, 
with that second red jet of light seeming to come out of nowhere. 
Do others feel the same? I will step back and say I have no idea 
now who else it could have been or why, if it really just is 
straight-forward Bella, JKR doesn't make it completely obvious 
by calling it "her second jet" instead of "the second jet" or 
something. It just leaves the door open for the sort of mystery 
that will drive me crazy until it is put to rest in a future book. 

And I will never believe in ESE!Lupin... even if it turns out to be 
true!  : (  Ack!

CDR - who hopes you haven't all permanently judged me as a 
freak over this post!