Wrapping up the Umbridge subplot

kizor0 ryokas at hotmail.com
Thu Aug 26 11:28:22 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 111270


> P.S.  Now, if we learn in passing in the next book that she IS in 
> Azkaban, or permanently mentally disabled (there is no indication in 
> OOTP that she won't be just fine shortly), or otherwise engaged in 
> long-term and severe suffering, THAT will wrap up the sub-plot nicely.

Unfortunately, with the amount of ire she's roused there's going to be
grumbling no matter what happens. Many will only consider it wrapped
up nicely if she meets a grisly enough end, and feeding her to a box
of Blast-Ended Skrewts may not be grisly enough.

(Personally, I think that reversing that last suggestion would
certainly satisfy all but a very few. Certainly there must be spells
that would make such a feat possible.)

- Kizor





More information about the HPforGrownups archive