[HPforGrownups] Re: Why is Tonks clumbsy?

[Alina]

No: HPFGUIDX 111610

> Lawless wrote:
>
> > She's "really" a he and has a hard time adjusting to the female
> center
> > of balance.
>
> > And these are all far-out guesses as to WHY Tonks is "really"
> male, with no
> > real canon backup, rather than her preference to her masculine
> surname over
> > her first name, and her unexplained clumbsiness.
> >
>

Actually, your theory gives new light to Tonks' words to Lupin, "You'd go by
your last name too if your mother named you Nymphadora." Sorry, that's
paraphrased. If Tonks is indeed a man, then those words make even more
sense, don't they? It's not really canon evidence, but it's something.

Alina.