Guarding the Stone

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Sat Dec 11 16:16:31 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 119713


Kneasy wrote:
> > > What I'd really like to know.... DD arrives in time to pull
Quirrell off Harry.
> > Harry remembers this - the voice, Quirrell's arms being wrenched
from his grasp.
> > Was Voldy still there?
> > Oh, and ignore film contamination, please.
> > 
> 
Tammy replied:
> I would say that Voldemort probably left when Quirrell was in so
much pain right around the time that the pain in Harry's scar made him
pass out. Whatever else that scar is, it does seem to be an indicator
of Voldemort's emotions, and that blinding pain that made Harry pass
out was probably going through Voldemort, with Voldemort's only option
> being to leave Quirrell's body. 
> 
> Of course that doesn't preclude the idea the Dumbledore arrived and
> did something to Quirrell/Voldemort to make Voldemort leave Quirrell. 
> 
> What I want to know is this: If Voldemort hadn't left before
Quirrell died, would Voldemort have died as well (too lazy to look up
if that's been discussed before :P )


Carol notes:
Voldemort says in GoF that Quirrell died when he (Voldemort) left
Quirrell's body--much the same fate suffered by the animals Voldy had
previously possessed. Assuming that he's telling the truth, he was
still inside Quirrell's head when Dumbledore came because Quirrell was
still alive and trying to kill Harry at that time. (Why would he still
want the stone if his master had left him, anyway?) In fact,
Dumbledore's presence was probably the reason LV left, escaping but
leaving his servant to die, his life and powers sapped by possession
and maybe by drinking the unicorn blood that, IMO, mad him
incorrigibly evil if he wasn't before. At any rate, Quirrell died
*because* Voldy left, and Dumbledore must have known that he had
resumed his existence at Vapor!mort.

Carol







More information about the HPforGrownups archive