ESE!Lupin

[olivier.fouquet+harry at m4x.org]

No: HPFGUIDX 120054

Ah Toto...

ESE! Lupin is a very dangerous an oh so evil werewolf indeed. Here is a 
sample of what he did:

1) Disgruntled with the discrimination against Werewolves and plagued 
with guilt for having betrayed Dumbledore, he started to spy for 
Voldemort one year before Harry's parents' death.
2) He managed to convince James to be his Secret-Keeper and then 
betrayed him.
3) Afterwards, he sent the Lestranges to torture the Longbottoms.
4) During the long years that followed, he actively worked to revive 
Voldemort.
5) In PoA, he purposefully did not take his potion in order to 
transform at the perfect time to kill Harry and Sirius. His plan 
backfired a bit, though he managed to have Peter escape. He was the one 
who sent the Dementors towards Harry and Sirius.
6) In GoF, he killed Cedric.
7) In OoP, he imperioed Sturgis Podmore, fed countless informations to 
Voldemort and killed Sirius.

I have never read that he was the one that planted Tom's diary amongst 
Ginny's books, but I suspect it was him nevertheless.

You can find all this brilliantly argued in posts by Pippin too 
numerous to count. If you search long enough, you will find motives, 
justifications and hints for all of the above in her messages. I assume 
and in fact hope she will introduce the theory herself in answer to 
your post.

Then again, some of us aren't still completely convinced.

Olivier